FROM THE INTERNATIONAL EMAIL BAG

From Lydia’s International Email Bag @ Givat Haviva

 

ANNA-CLARA BIRGESSON, SWEDEN

“Our seminar was inspirational – everybody thought so,” emailed Anna-Clara Birgersson following a visit to Givat Haviva and Kibbutz Mishmar HaEmek with a group of international Ecumenical Accompaniers volunteering for 3 months in the West Bank.

Anna-Clara, a physiotherapist and psychotherapist “believes in the power of prayer and creative arts, and especially in peace building through expressive arts and that prayers in action generate change in meetings between people.”

Together with other Accompaniers hailing from South Africa, Poland, Hungary, Germany, Norway, Switzerland, America and Britain, Anna-Clara and friends spent a few hours visiting the Arab Muslim village of Barta’a and area as well as visiting Mishmar HaEmek, the kibbutz of their guide for the day and Givat Haviva staff member Lydia Aisenberg and where the subject of community and the kibbutz movement discussed. 

 

Ecumenical Accompaniers visiting Barta’a

 

picnic lunch in Kibbutz Mishmar HaEmek

 

RONEET KAHAN, LOS ANGELES

“Everyone enjoyed the talk and wished that we could have carved out extra time to see what else could have been included.  Many in the group came up to us and said they regretted the we could not spend more time – we will just have to continue on the next trip to Israel!” so wrote Roneet, one of a group of 30 friends from the Los Angeles visiting the country – some of whom having been to Israel many times before.

 

RAPHAEL SHAINFARBER, OTTAWA, CANADA

A student studying in Ottawa and due to take up the position of vice-President of the local Hillel in the coming academic year, Raphael Shainfarber sent the following email upon his return home.

“I have now safely returned home to Canada.  I wanted to thank you once more for the extremely valuable educational experience that you provided during our visit (June 15th and 16th).

Indeed, when you agreed to show us around, I was eager to see and learn but I did not quite know what it was that I would be able to take away from the experience.  Upon reflection, spending time touring the West Bank and seeing the history first hand has made the “conflict” much more real for me.  Specifically, meeting real Palestinians has put a “human face” on the conflict that no news report could ever do.

Moreover, standing on a mountain top looking at the West Bank on one side and the very flat state of Israel on the other, one cannot help but gain a greater understanding of the complex nature and importance of the geography.

In the coming days and weeks, as I continue to reflect upon my entire trip, I know that my ideas will continue to develop.  As they do, I hope to be able to put some into writing.

I would like to thank you for providing me with such a meaningful experience. 

Warm regards, Raffi.”

 

Raphael Shainfarber (blue t-shirt right) and friends Alan Borenstein, Daryn Epstein and Dave Abrahm meeting

with Rateb Kabha, a Palestinian barber in the West Bank village of East Barta’a 

 

JEREMY MARKS, ENGLAND - Participating in a Birthright group from Britain comprising both students and young professionals, dental graduate Jeremy Marks found himself at with Givat Haviva.

Back home in London Jeremy’s father, Peter Marks, is the chairman of the British Friends of Givat Haviva and who also participated in such a tour in the past.

Jeremy emailed that he found the talk given with regard the Arab citizens of Israel “to be both informative and useful and had greater impact actually being in/near the area in question itself as opposed to reading about it in London.

Everyone in the group was really grateful and found the whole morning very insightful.”

 

Jeremy Marks by the Birthright bus out and about in Wadi Ara

 

JAN SCHNEIDER, GERMANY

“I was among the German delegation that you gave a fine tour to the settlement area of Katzir and Harish and the villages of Barta’a last November.

I appreciated your presentation a lot and drew quite some knowledge from it, which also – at least indirectly – influenced a recent paper I wrote on Israel as an immigrant country.

So thanks a lot!

Maybe you will find the paper interesting or you could forward it to some of your potentially interested peers or colleagues (see download link below).

Best regards from Berlin/Hamburg,

Jan.”

www.focus-migration.de/Israel.5246.0.html?&L=1

 

PAM PEARLMUTTER, Director, Passport to Israel, Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia emailed upon return to AMERICA.

Lydia – thank you so much for the day we spent with you.  We had a follow up to the trip and you really made an impact on all the participants, including me.

The kids loved being with you and the experience in Barta’a made them realize how close and complicated the situation in Israel really is.

It was my pleasure meeting you and look forward to meeting again in the future.

Pam Pearlmutter.”

 

ROLAND HINUEBER, Photojournalist, GERMANY

“It was a great day with you – not just interesting to listen to you, it was also fun.  I really appreciated your Welsh humor.

I will come back to you on my next trip to Israel.  I would like to know more about the locals and would be good to have you as our guide.

Kind regards from the green and currently wet Rhineland, Roland.”

 

       

Photographs sent by photojournalist Roland Hinueber of Lydia in Umm el Fahm and talking with Palestinians at the Reichan checkpoint

 

LENA JERSENIUS, STOCKHOLM, SWEDEN.

Co-chairperson of the Committee Against Anti-Semitism and Racism, Lena headed a Swedish delegation of educators in Israel for a Yad VaShem program and 2 day seminar with Givat Haviva.

“Thank you very much for taking so good care of us when we were in Israel.

The group was extremely satisfied and in an evaluation someone suggested we rate our different activities and not surprisingly you had the top position!

You are doing a tremendous job explaining positions, situations and showing places. 

The Middle East is so difficult to “read” and my Swedish colleagues being typical Swedes have a hard time leaving Swedish stances and putting themselves in another context,” emailed Lena from Stockholm.

ANNAKARIN THORN, one of the Swedish teachers in a separate email wrote:

“For me, the time we spend together with you was the most memorable and important day of our whole trip to Israel, especially the visit to the Israeli/Palestinian village and the checkpoint were very special experiences for me.

I feel very grateful to have been able to see those places.  The meeting with you and the visit to the different places in the West Bank has given me a better and wider understanding and perspective about the conflict,” commented Annakarin also from Stockholm.

 

Swedish teachers at Holocaust Memorial in Kibbutz Mishmar HaEmek

 

outside the girl’s high school in East Barta’a

 

CHRISTINA WHITELAW, a British educator living in GERMANY

“I’m the Scotswoman who was on the road recently with the German teachers and had the incredible good fortune to stumble your way at Givat Haviva.

Thanks for the insight you gave us, have been thinking about it ever since.  I was also glad to get your articles a colleague passed on to all of us.

My dream would be to take some of my knowledge-thirsty pupils to work on the campus in some way!”

JOSHUA, NA’AMA and SEGEV YARDEN, Philadelphia

Josh Yarden and family are Israelis living in Philadelphia where Josh is involved in teaching Jewish educators about Israel and Na’ama on the teaching staff of a Jewish school.

Whilst in Israel recently to celebrate the bar mitzvah of Segev, the Yarden’s visited Givat Haviva (where Josh had both studied and taught quite some years ago) and embarked with Lydia on a Green Line tour.

An email from Josh:

Lydia – thanks again so much for the tour.  It was quite interesting to see how things have changed over the years.  The stories you add and your personal connections to the people we met really make the visit come alive.  Just as the places we visited are hidden beyond the hilltop over the Wadi Ara road, so the reality of the residents (and really Israeli society in general) escapes the attention of tourists and Israeli residents alike. I’m glad we had the opportunity to add that element to our trip.”

 

   

  Left: SEGEV YARDEN at the Mei Ami stretch of the security fence and with parents Josh and Na’ama overlooking Barta’a village and the Dotan Valley

 

Thanks everybody for your encouraging emails and look forward to meeting you again when you next visit Israel.

Toda, shukran, thanks and merci!  Lydia

 

Last Update: